Poetry Turing Test

If you've read this blog previously you'll know that I'm both a poet and a computer scientist. Recently I have been researching the alleged capability of OpenAI's ChatGPT to write poetry. Some have expressed concerns that AI will soon replace poets, artists, musicians and other creatives. So I thought I would perform a little experiment. Here's a challenge for you: A sort of poetry Turing Test if you will. Can you tell the difference between a computer generated poem and one written by a human being? 

Earlier today I asked ChatGPT to write a Pantoum about love. I also wrote a Pantoum, based on the same rules of the fixed form poem. Both are below. But which one is the AI generated poem... and which is mine? I welcome all of your comments. 

1: LOVE ON FIRE

Love, a feeling that never fades,

An eternal flame that burns within,

A bond that lasts through all the shades,

A journey that never has an end.

An eternal flame that burns within,

A warmth that spreads from heart to heart,

A journey that never has an end,

A connection that's never torn apart.

A warmth that spreads from heart to heart,

A spark that ignites a fiery passion,

A connection that's never torn apart,

A love that defies all reason.

A spark that ignites a fiery passion,

A bond that lasts through all the shades,

A love that defies all reason,

Love, a feeling that never fades.

2: LOVE ON FIRE

I dream of love that never fades,

Igniting flames that rage like sin,

A fire that warms when cold invades,

Hot furnace, blazing deep within

Igniting flames that rage like sin,

A spark that leaps from heart to heart,

Hot furnace, blazing deep within,

A conflagration work of art.

A spark that leaps from heart to heart,

With embers that can never die

A conflagration work of art,

A love that reaches to the sky

With embers that can never die,

A fire that warms when cold invades,

A love that reaches to the sky,

I dream of love that never fades

Image licenced under Creative Commons